What's the point(s)? |
However, having no wish to see Gospodin Lavrov laughed at in
public, I have a consoling suggestion to make about the reason why Azerbaijan
gave the Russian entry no points. The idea occurred to me when I watched the
video to see what all the fuss was about (see here). To my surprise, I noticed
that it was sung in English. Then it dawned upon me that the Azerbaijanis
probably did not understand a word of it.
If the Soviet Union had been more attentive towards teaching
the international language to its subject nationalities, and had had less of an
inferiority complex about speaking English, then those judges down in Baku or
wherever might have got the message and been able to sympathise with the words
of the Russian crooner.
But then again, listening to the words, I wonder. I felt as
if I was watching to someone on “Russia’s Got Talent” auditioning for an
understudy in a 1980s musical about Jennifer Rush. I am not sure I’d’ve given
the song many votes, even I had known that doing so might have risked making Mr
Lavrov burst into tears at the humiliation of it all. One has, after all, one’s
moral integrity to consider, even when it comes to International Farting
Competitions.
But a final, positive, point: Russian is a much more
attractive-sounding a language for crooning than English. It can convey a sense of
mystification with especial force outside the former Soviet Union, because we in the English-speaking world were (and are) so much worse at languages than even the Russians (who are not that great). I think the song would have done much better both inside and outside Azerbaijan if it had been sung in Russian. The time for linguistic inferiority complexes is long past. Modern up, Sergei old chap! Who wants to hear Nezhnost, or even
Podmoskovnye Vechera, sung in English, after all (except, perhaps, in a “creative” way by
Bob Dylan, say, or Sid Vicious, two inferior singers who refused to accept their vocal limitations)?
So true. Shame to see news like this.
ReplyDeleteI am having hard time understanding why Lavrov did that. One hypothesis is that the president himself might be a disappointed viewer (http://avmalgin.livejournal.com/3801306.html). If true, this only proves your point on inferiority complex.
Steady on, old chap! At a time when British politcos and chattering classes are obsessed with dancing attendance on something called 'Gay Marriage', I find Mr. Lavrov's concentration on the important matters of the day to be refreshing and appropriate. And God bless Eurovision for ensuring that modern European wars are fought in the crooner-sphere and not on physical battlefields. More scandalous - and even more entertaining - is the simmering Euro-resentment towards the UK, which ensures that even a delightful songstress like Ms Botox..sorry Bonny Tyler is ignored into oblivion. What's Mr. Vague doing about that? FA at the FO, pusillanimous as ever. So hats off to Mr.L for sticking up for his country's vital interests. Russia needs more of this robust diplomacy
ReplyDeleteLooks like almost everything make Russia 'a laughing stock' in your opinion, Ian :).
ReplyDeleteIt's funny that Lavrov mentioned that but on the other hand I was watching the contest here, in Britain, it looked like I wasn't the only one watching it with interest, it's very popular in Britain too. And there were quite a few debates on Bonny Tyler - I mean British people take this contest close to heart to.
And, seriously, Ian, you have Boris Johnson in the UK - Russians are not the only nation to have politicians at whose words they can laugh hysterically!